Wednesday, October 22, 2008

Weekly Crisis Comic Book Reviews for 10/22/08

Seeing as the two big event books came out at the same time, I decided to limit this edition of the Weekly Crisis Comic Book Reviews to those two titles - may the best issue win. I'll be updating tomorrow with the rest of the reviews, but, for now, hit the jump to find out what I thought of Final Crisis #4 and Secret Invasion #7. I'm sure at least one of the verdicts will shock you.

Written by Grant Morrison
Art by J.G. Jones and Carlos Pacheco

It's been quite a while since Final Crisis #3 and, since then, we've seen several tie-ins and we're being greeted with the addition of a fill-in, er, I mean, collaborating artist, who was brought on board to help Jones. How did the long layoff and artist change affect my feelings on this event? Read on to find out.

First off, Final Crisis #4 is easily the best issue of the series. While it wasn't perfect, it was far better than anything that came before it for many, very simple, reasons.

One such reason is that the writing seems to be focused and Morrison appears to have a clear agenda as to what he wants to tell us after the time-skip. Gone are the schizophrenic jumps between unrelated plot points and we are left with a story that, while still as dense and jam packed with near encylopedic knowledge of the DCU, is both straight forward for casual readers and rewarding for those that have put the time into reading the various storylines Morrison draws upon.

Picking up roughly one month later, Final Crisis #4 depicts a world caught in the throes of the Anti-Life Equation. We quickly jump between the various surviving heroes and their safehouses or Watchtowers, as they are calling them. These include the Fortress of Solitude, JLA Hall of Justice, Checkmate's castle and several other super-hero bases. We're also treated to glimpses of the world as it is now with Anti-Life Justifiers systematically seizing control of every major population center and, in general, showing off the affects of the Anti-Life Equation on Earth. It paints a grim picture and has done its job of making Final Crisis into a Crisis-level event, moreso than any other save the original Crisis.

However, the real stars of this show are the Flashes and Green Arrow. Morrison has a firm grasp of these three characters and, with only a few pages featuring him, has gone a long way towards selling the whole return of Barry Allan to me. Whether it was Wally and Barry's brief dialogue about his being back (Flash fact!) or Barry and Iris embracing, Barry stole every page he was on. Now, whether that's a good thing for poor Wally or not is hard to say...

On the Green Arrow side of things, he definitely had the best lines of the issue with his "Anti-Anti-Life Arrow" and his slight alterations to the Justifiers', "Anti-Life justifies our actions.", line. After nothing but Winnick's Green Arrow to read, it was nice to see some quality Ollie action for a change.

In fact, the only thing I really disliked about this issue was Darkseid, or the lack thereof. For months, we've been teased with that cover image of Darkseid and told how everything changes with issue four when we finally see what happens when evil wins. Well, we saw the consequences of evil winning, but we never even see the big baddie until the very last page of the issue, where, after struggling to contain Darkseid's essence for most of the issue, Turpin finally falters and Darkseid's persona emerges, red eyes, concrete skin and all, giving a big thumbs down to life on Earth. These were all written extremely well and I did enjoy the way it was handled, but I was just expecting, with a time skip and all, that we'd see Darkseid triumphant and in action. Not sitting in a chair being contained by one human's strength of will for 30 pages.

Okay, I lied about only disliking one thing. There is one other thing that I have to talk about before wrapping this review up and it's the art. While many decried Final Crisis and called DC down from on high when they announced the art changes / addition of Pacheco to the event, I think it's safe to say that, while the change is fairly noticable, it's far from the worst thing to ever happen to a title and Pacheco does the be he can to emulate Jones' work.

However, while Pacheco does a great job emulating the style, he certainly lacks in the details. Every hero and villain looks fairly similar to scenes clearly drawn by Jones, but Pacheco's backgrounds are bland and barren by comparison. Many look like they were simply white washed with non-descript walls, giving a 'floating heads' or body look to the panels.

In the end, though, the only people I can see really being upset about the art are people that are just looking for another reason to bash a book they probably aren't even reading. This isn't Countdown quality fill-in art and they did a great job breaking the two up into various subplots in the book, giving each storyline its own feeling while still remaining similar in style. To be honest, it's better than I anticipated and I imagine Pacheco was rushed in to fix this before any delays occurred. I imagine, in future issues, his work will look much better than this and, as I said, this is far bad artwork as it is.

Verdict - Must Read. I think it's safe to say this event starts with this issue. I'd honestly recommend not even reading the first three issues at this point. All you need to know is evil won and this is the aftermath and you should be able to enjoy every aspect of this issue with even the vaguest knowledge of DC. Oh, but make sure to read Final Crisis: Submit first. It fills in a fairly large chunk of story for the Hall of Justice scene with Black Lightning and the Tattoo Man.

Written by Brian Bendis
Art by Leinil Yu

Boom. Blam. Kapow. Noh-Var shows up for one panel, never appears again. Hawkeye shoots some Skrulls in the face. Wasp prepares to blow up due to the Skrull Hank Pym's growing formula, which he gave to her in the opening arc of Mighty Avengers. The end.

That's the entire issue's story in a nutshell and it's about as boring and predictable to read (if you can call looking at pictures of generic, non-descript 'big action scenes' reading) as the description I just gave.

If this wasn't enough to make it abundantly clear that Secret Invasion is, and will be, a complete dud when it's all said and done, several other books this week, most notably Captain America, spoil the big 'shock ending' of Wasp possibly killing everyone by telling us everyone survived and things are fine on Earth post-SI.

On the plus side for this issue, Yu's art is quite good and he does a great job rendering the huge cast of heroes and villains. He makes this the popcorn action flick of a comic book that many people are enjoying about with this series and I'm surprised at how much I'm enjoying his artwork on this type of project. However, he does get a little lazy with the Skrulls and many turn into non-descript blobs, but when there's literally dozens of them filling up the backgrounds, I can cut him some slack on that.

The only other positive I can think of was the amount of useage Stature, of Young Avengers fame, received. She took down both the Galactus Skrull and the Hank Pym one in two splashpages. I assume Bendis is priming her or a spot on the new Mighty team post-SI.

This type of generic action filling up an entire issue (well, entire event in SI's case) doesn't agree with me and if you've been enjoying this series up until now, you'll continue to love it with this issue.

For me, I just can't get into it. We never receive any resolution to any of the fights the heroes are having with any of the Skrulls. It's just one generic, "Here's character X's powers in action!", followed by, "and here's character Y doing something cool!", ad nauseum for 25 pages or more. We spent months prepping a "secret invasion", marking one of the most covert and insidious take overs by an alien force in all of Marvel's history and the big conclusion is a frat party brawl in downtown New York. What the hell kind of planning did these Skrulls do? This is just pandering to fans looking for the next big fight or looking for their favourite character to "do something cool".

The thing that bothered me the most was the whole Noh-Var joining the battle scene. Bendis has everyone stop and look at this incoming and unidentified super-powered character and we get an awesome reveal of Noh-Var claiming to represent Captain Marvel and the Kree Empire and making it known the Skrulls are finished here and we never see him again. It's like every other appearance by him or Captain Marvel since this event started - it's a waste of time and a complete throwaway on Bendis' part. There's no follow up nor even any other mention of who he is or why the scene should be important and it's forgotten by the reader, and Bendis, as quickly as it happened.

The story telling of this event is like that of a child telling his parent his idea for a cool story. Bendis fails to follow up on any of his plots and just goes from one big idea to the next with no follow through, let alone a follow up. It's just one big explosion or reveal after another for the entire event and that is its biggest failing in my eyes.

Verdict - Avoid It. Go back and read my opening summary. That's all that happens. If you want to look at some big explosions and pin-up style fight scenes with no real story telling or flow to them, feel free to get this then.

Related Posts


Andrenn said...

Too bad to hear that SI is sucking. I have serious doubts that 8 can redeem these last 2 issues.

Actually happy to hear FC was good, may pick up #4.

dberes said...

I'm proud of you, Kirk.

Krod said...

I agree. Final Crisis filled me with apathy until this issue. I read Final Crisis #4 and Final Crisis: Submit and was won over.

Secret Invasion took me two sittings because I quit part way through. It is so terribly written! Does Bendis not have an editor to challenge him? No choreography to the action... just splash panels. Characters with this bizarre.. well, everyone knows by now how Bendis writes dialogue without any character. Why do I care about these characters and what is going on, Bendis? Stop having characters tell us how big and important and wowing this is and show us through the story. And showing us doesn't mean trying to have every character the artist can look up drawn onto the pages. Numbers. Mean. Nothing. Any character could have been anyone else for all they mattered. I'll bet the script didn't even have what characters were in the story in it. I'll bet it just said to have a bunch of characters doing who cares what.

"The story telling of this event is like that of a child telling his parent his idea for a cool story."

Spot on! This story wasn't developed past an initial conceptual phase.

Cat said...

Final Crisis has started to redeem itself this week. I was very impressed with the writing in both the main book and One shot. I know some people swear by them, but I was completely and utterly put off by the first 3 issues.

Anyone read the new Amazing Spider-Man? Good little story. I'm in the Military, so I may be biased :-)

Kiko said...

i still didnt like final crisis. it still had lines that are really painful to read. "i was the one who killed the internet!" and the anti-life equation actually being an english emotional equation still doesnt impress me.the series still feels like someone shouting look at me im a big event look at me! yet still feels will be inconsequential after it is all over.

mugiwara said...

I guess Bendis used Cassie so much just because there wasn't other giant in heroes' side.

As usual, Bendis and Yu showed their limitation when it comes to show a big fight between super powered teams. I wanted to see some various powers in action, like Gauntlet's or Songbird's, but for the most it was just people punching and blasting things.

I just hope that it next issue, Sentry/Void will come back and hurl Janet into the sun. (I'm a sucker for recurrent jokes)

Parallax207 said...

I really enjoyed the Submit one-shot. Why is it that the one-shots and mini-series of these huge crossover events sometimes outshine the event itself? Final Crisis 4 was really interesting especially the final pages; an interesting twist I didn't see coming. (I do agree that 1-3 were basically throwaways; they should have made that like a double-sized 1-shot, like with the beginning of the Sinestro-Corps War.) As for Secret Invasion 7 I always postulated that Noh-Varr would be an important part of the event... What a shame that he just appears for a second and that was that... maybe he will have a bigger impact on Dark Reign.

barryreese said...

It's funny you diss Pacheco somewhat here. His pages were the best in the book to me and I much prefer his work to Jones.

SalieriTheFish said...

Kiko - as explained elsewhere, the form of the Equation that you see is just the way that the Equation appears when interpreted in human terms. The actual ALE is a far more abstract and unfathomable concept, far more powerful when we know nothing of it - which is why we never see it. Even in 'Seven Soldiers: Mister Miracle' its appears as this obscure black swirl in Darkseid's speech bubble.

More on that here:

ComicsAllTooReal's Chris said...

Sadly, I didn't like none of these two books.

Final Crisis is far from being casual reader friendly. The entire deal is encyclopedic at best, and it doesn't help that the New Gods look so different and very little is explained in the book. I struggled and I'm a New God's fan, so, figures!

While I have to agree with the fact that also Secret Invasion was disappointing (after all the build up of a great plot, things have stalled for too long). Still, I wouldn't call Final Crisis #4 a winning book. I'm still surprised by the lack of emotion written into the dramatic scenes. The reunion of the Flashes was as dull as the Martian Manhunter's death. And this is the same guy who wrote Animal Man so many years ago! Sadly, I find him like a robot writer, these days. Lots of facts, zero emotions.

dberes said...

Kirk, I've posted my own thoughts on FC#4 on my blog, if you might be interested in reading them. Seeing as how we butted heads over the last issue, I thought I would let you know. :p

oakleyses said...

true religion outlet, coach outlet, oakley sunglasses, nike air max, longchamp outlet, prada outlet, chanel handbags, michael kors outlet, prada handbags, gucci handbags, nike outlet, tiffany jewelry, christian louboutin uk, michael kors outlet online, oakley sunglasses wholesale, nike air max, michael kors outlet online, tiffany and co, coach outlet store online, longchamp outlet, kate spade outlet, oakley sunglasses, coach outlet, kate spade, replica watches, coach purses, burberry outlet, ray ban sunglasses, polo ralph lauren outlet online, christian louboutin, burberry handbags, christian louboutin outlet, michael kors outlet online, tory burch outlet, michael kors outlet, longchamp outlet, jordan shoes, christian louboutin shoes, ray ban sunglasses, michael kors outlet store, nike free, polo outlet

oakleyses said...

ralph lauren uk, polo lacoste, mulberry uk, sac longchamp pas cher, lululemon canada, true religion outlet, nike blazer pas cher, north face uk, nike air max, burberry pas cher, nike free uk, sac vanessa bruno, michael kors, converse pas cher, abercrombie and fitch uk, ray ban pas cher, ray ban uk, michael kors pas cher, hollister pas cher, timberland pas cher, hollister uk, nike free run, nike air max uk, jordan pas cher, nike air force, air max, louboutin pas cher, oakley pas cher, sac hermes, guess pas cher, new balance, nike air max uk, north face, michael kors outlet, true religion outlet, longchamp pas cher, nike tn, hogan outlet, vans pas cher, nike roshe, polo ralph lauren, true religion jeans

oakleyses said...

north face outlet, oakley, soccer jerseys, hollister, ghd hair, beats by dre, chi flat iron, new balance shoes, vans outlet, babyliss, reebok outlet, nike roshe run, nike huaraches, nike roshe run uk, instyler, iphone 6 cases, nfl jerseys, mcm handbags, hollister clothing, insanity workout, wedding dresses, giuseppe zanotti outlet, nike trainers uk, longchamp uk, p90x workout, mont blanc pens, north face outlet, asics running shoes, abercrombie and fitch, mac cosmetics, soccer shoes, nike air max, hermes belt, herve leger, jimmy choo outlet, celine handbags, baseball bats, bottega veneta, lululemon, timberland boots, ferragamo shoes, valentino shoes

oakleyses said...

ugg,uggs,uggs canada, ugg uk, hollister, lancel, ray ban, replica watches, juicy couture outlet, pandora charms, nike air max, marc jacobs, juicy couture outlet, ugg boots, hollister, uggs on sale, converse outlet, montre pas cher, toms shoes, ugg, converse, ugg pas cher, links of london, ugg,ugg australia,ugg italia, karen millen uk, gucci, pandora uk, supra shoes, wedding dresses, thomas sabo, louboutin, pandora jewelry, swarovski, ralph lauren, swarovski crystal, uggs outlet, coach outlet, ugg boots, uggs outlet, vans

Post a Comment

Thanks for checking out the Weekly Crisis - Comic Book Review Blog. Comments are always appreciated. You can sign in and comment with any Google, Wordpress, Live Journal, AIM, OpenID or TypePad account.