Friday, June 4, 2010

Comic Book Review Power Rankings for 06/03/10

It’s a short week for the Comic Book Review Power Rankings, but we’ve got quantity over quality as all five of this week’s comics are definitely worth a read. With a short stack, it is always a fierce battle for Book of the Week honors, but only one can talk away with the top spot. Will it be the debut of Marvel’s Hawkeye and Mockingbird? Or perhaps it is the conclusion of Mice Templar: Destiny? Heck, it might even be the first issue of the Sky-Doll: Spaceship Collection anthology. There is only one way to find out—that’s to hit the jump and read on!

For the uninitiated, the Comic Book Review Power Rankings is a countdown from worst-to-best of my weekly comic book haul. Before reading the issues, I preRank them based on the creative team, previous issues, solicitations, and gut instinct. The final Ranking number is based upon how the issues actually turned out. I attempt to keep everything as spoiler free as possible, but keep in mind that there may be the occasional minor spoiler that I overlook. As always, I can be reached via responses to this thread or at

Written by Jim McCann
Art by David Lopez, Alvaro Lopez, and Nathan Fairbairn
Letters by Cory Petit
Cover by Paul Renaud
preRanking: 05

• If this weren’t such a short week, I don’t think I would have tried out the debut issue of Hawkeye and Mockingbird, as I hate to add another title to my pull list, but general curiosity and a love for the original Hawkeye miniseries that introduced Mockingbird got the best of me and so I picked it up.
• This is a solid debut issue with writer Jim McCann focusing mainly on introducing the current status quo for the characters, including Mockingbird’s new spy agency, while simultaneously setting up two villainous threats.
• I think the major draw on this series is going to be Hawkeye, but if you aren’t up to speed on Mockingbird’s history, it is easy to get lost on the details here without reading the retrospective on the characters at the end of the issue.
• The main problem with the issue, though, is the pacing. The narration from Hawkeye and the dialogue with all of the characters is super thick, which throws off the pacing, especially during the action-packed moments at the beginning of the issue. That disconnect pulled me out of the issue several times.
• McCann has a way with the characters though, as everyone has super strong personalities that really carry this issue. I was especially impressed with the interlude between Hawkeye and both Captain Americas, which had a great “boys’ club” feel that was a nice change of pace.
• I haven’t seen much from David Lopez and Alvaro Lopez since their stint on Catwoman, but I’m glad to see that they haven’t lost a step since then.
• The level of detail does fluctuate quite a bit on the backgrounds, but the main character work is really solid and I dig their approach to storytelling.
• The story is built on a pretty standard grid approach, but the artists put some twists on how those grids are laid out, which kept things fresh throughout the issue.
• The only major issue I had with the art is the weird chins that plague the issue. Everyone from Hawkeye to Captain America to even Mockingbird has a Jay Leno-esque chin at least once in this issue, which isn’t something I cared for.

Verdict: Check It. This issue just barely missed the mark for a Buy It verdict, mostly because of the awkward pacing that made it hard to trudge through on my first read-through and the prerequisite knowledge of Mockingbird’s history that you really need to have to get the full extent of this issue. I really dug McCann’s approach to the characters through and the art team worked well with him. This is certainly a fun issue that has me convinced to come back for more as this series has loads of potential.

Written by Barbara Canepa and Alessandro Barbucci
Translated and Adapted by Matteo Casali and Jim McCann
Art by Mateo De Longis, Claudio Acclari, and Pierre-Mony Chan
Letters by Clay Cowles
Cover by Barbara Canepa and Alessandro Barbucci
preRanking: 03

Sky-Doll returns this week with The Spaceship Collection, an anthology of stories loosely related to the original comic that flesh out the world of our heroine Noa without being bogged down by oppressive continuity or the heavy themes of the original story.
• As a HUGE fan of the original story, I really dug this, but it is worth noting that it is absolutely essential that you have some familiarity with the franchise before approaching this comic or you are going to be totally lost.
• You wouldn’t think that it would make that big of a difference, but the change from CB Cebulski to Jim McCann as the adaptor of the comic does affect the tone and cadence of the writing. It’s not a major issue, but it is noticeable.
• The lead story of this comic is the weakest as it is much harder to follow than the others because of how much is left unsaid. Its darker themes of abandonment and tragic existentialism are more in line with the original, but don’t quite gel as well with the lightheartedness of the other stories in this collection.
• In terms of art, Mateo de Longis’s work is a very close fit to the original as he rarely strays from the style set by Canepa and Barbucci.
• The second story, which riffs on the old west (but with lasers) is incredibly goofy and a major departure in tone for the series. It’s incredibly fun, but feels out of place in the larger picture.
• The art took some getting used to as the flat, bleeding colors are far more European than I’m used to, but once I got the hang of it, it had a cool, almost graphitti-like quality to it.
• The third story was certainly the strongest as it felt to be a direct extension of the original, focusing on Noa’s time at the brothel with other Dolls. It’s a bit more frantic and has a lighthearted tone similar to the second story. The solid character work and fun approach made it the most well-rounded of the three stories and the amin draw.
• The art in the story has a very Eastern look, aping the stereotypical feel often associated with manga. It’s look and energetic with great expressions and a perfect fit for the story.
• The comic is then rounded out with a great production design and some fun concept art in the back matter.

Verdict: Buy It. For fans of the Sky-Doll franchise, this is a nice “distraction” while we wait for the fourth chapter in the ongoing story by creators Barbara Canepa and Allessandro Barbucci. It doesn’t quite live up to the standards of the original, but is still a very fun comic and something that should appeal to the desired audience. Personally, I think it would make a great addition to a Sky Doll omnibus, should Marvel and Soliel choose to release one.

Written by Dan Abnett and Andy Lanning
Art by Miguel Sepulveda and Jay David Ramos
Letters by Joe Caramagna
Cover by Aleksi Briclot
preRanking: 02

• Spinning out of last week’s Thanos Imperative: Ignition, Marvel’s newest cosmic even kicks off this week with nearly all of Marvel’s prominent cosmic heroes find themselves pitted against Lord Mar-Vell’s forces from inside The Fault (the “Cancerverse”) as the Guardians of the Galaxy form an unlikely alliance with Thanos.
• This issue kicks off with a lot of action and flows cleanly from page one into a great cliffhanger thanks to its absolutely superb pacing. Dan Abnett and Andy Lanning make it clear from page one that this is meant to be a blockbuster as they never let up from cover to cover.
• Not surprisingly, you get great character work all around with a huge cast. Of course, it helps that DnA have spent the last few years finely crafting all of Marvel’s cosmic characters to the point that even throwaway lines from guys like Karnak have tons of personality.
• The only moment in the entire issue where I would say the character writing could use some work was the opening scene with Star-Lord and Nova, which felt a bit clunky and awkward. Beyond that, however, this is DnA at their finest.
• For example, the scene where Rocket Raccoon threatens and successfully intimidates Thanos while wearing a BioShock-esque exoskeleton. In that scene, DnA get to the heart of the characters and manage to really boost Rocket without shortchanging Thanos.
• Or, in my favorite moment of the entire issue, they have Thanos offering up his thanks and respect to Drax for killing him during Annihilation. It is a scene you’d never expect and that, in theory, would never work, but DnA pull it off superbly.
• In terms of writing, this is right up there amongst the finest issues that this writing team has put together. If you dig their work (which you should), this will be right up your alley.
• The problem with the issue lines in the art, which is unfortunate, because there is absolutely no reason for this problem to exist, nor is there any reason that we should know that it is a problem in the first place.
• If you look at the art on its own, it is pretty solid. The designs are strong and the storytelling works extremely well. Miguel Sepulveda holds his own throughout the issue and does a solid job of working with a large cast and a very insane concept.
• When you look at the pencil-only previews for issue #2, however, you realize exactly how much is lost in this issue when it is colored. It looks like the colors were done directly overtop the pencils, which takes away loads of detail and a lot of the style that Sepulveda brings to the table.
• I honestly would have had no idea what the art was capable of and wouldn’t have minded what we got were it not for these preview pages, but after seeing them, I can’t help but feel disappointed by the end result.
• I think if an inker was brought in to tighten up those details and separate the line work from the art, this would be a vastly different and vastly more impressive issue.
• I’m not going to lie, though, the double-page spread of Galactus and pals from the preview pages was one of the coolest things I’ve seen all week and I’m glad that we were able to see it in its rawest, and potentially finest, form.

Verdict: Buy It. I really want to give this issue a Must Read and I’ll probably regret holding it back at Buy it, but after seeing what the potential of the art, I can’t help but feel that the coloring in this issue was a large enough miss that it drags down the entire issue. Don’t get me wrong though, this is still an amazing issue with some awesome action and some of the finest character moments DnA have ever written. You shouldn’t miss it, but be warned about the art.

02. RED ROBIN #13
Written by Fabian Nicieza
Art by Marcus To, Ray McCarthy, Mark McKenna, and Guy Major
Letters by Sal Cipriano
Cover by Marcus To
preRanking: 04

• Prior to Batman RIP, Fabian Nicieza made the Robin solo series one of the best comics DC was producing as he closed out the series so that Chris Yost could launch Red Robin. Nicieza comes back to Tim Drake this week and proves that he has not lost a single step in the last year.
• In Nicieza’s first issue back, Tim reflects on the good place that his life finally is in as he starts his new mission to completely clean up the streets of Gotham, starting with gang leader-turned ally-turned threat Lynx.
• This issue felt like an extension of Yost’s run as Nicieza picks up a lot of direction and plot threads from the first twelve issues while still going in his own direction that is an extension of his final few issues of the Robin ongoing.
• The character work here is incredible as Nicieza slips back into writing Tim without a single problem. He just “gets” the character and makes it clear from the get go what his concept of the character is in this issue.
• I dig that, without upsetting the cart, we relearn the character’s world view, his relationships, and his particular commitment to being a superhero. Nicieza does a brilliant job with the transition.
Marcus To has immediate chemistry with Ncieza, thanks in part to how well the script transitions between writers. I think we’ll see the same success with this creative team as we did the last.
• To’s storytelling and pacing here as fantastic, as he works in perfect sync with the script to beuild intensity from the lighthearted early scenes towards some great action and the very determined focus of the final few pages.
• What really impressed me, however, is how well To expresses the tone of the issue without having to alter his style. While thematically this feels like an extension of Yost’s run, it has a unique tone and To finds it quickly without abandoning what worked well for him in the previous issues.

Verdict: Must Read. Transitions from one very strong run to a new creative team tend to be some of my least favorite issues; it seems like the more I liked the previous direction, the harder it is for me to stay entertained while the new creative team finds its legs. That doesn’t happen here. In fact, there isn’t a moment where I even remotely lost interest in Red Robin while reading this issue. Nicieza jumps immediately into old form as he picks up the reigns on Tim Drake, firmly establishing the new direction of this issue while still spinning out of Yost’s superb run. This issue works on nearly every level and you’d be a fool to miss it!

Written by Bryan J.L. Glass
Art by Victor Santos and Veronica Gandini
Letters by James H. Glass
Cover by Michael Golden
preRanking: 01

• I’ll admit, I’m a junkie for Mice Templar. I’ve loved this series from the very first issue and is always at the top of my recommendations to folks looking for a new comic to read. That being said, I also hold the comic to ridiculously high standards. Sometimes, I even have my doubts that the series can live up them. Then an issue like this comes along and proves that I had absolutely no idea what the franchise is capable of and shows me that my already insanely highly standards simply weren’t high enough.
• In the final issue of this volume, Karic unleashes his attack on the Snake God in his desperate and dangerous attempt to save his family and friends that were abducted from Cricket’s Glen in the very first issue of the very first volume of this series. Meanwhile, the many subplots all come together as plans are hatched, foiled, and created in a densely packed and exciting issue.
• This is certainly one of the most intense issues of the entire year. It’s so intense that I’m amazed that the creative team was able to keep everything so focused as it shifts from scene to scene, covering an absurd amount of story and conveying so much chaos. Kudos to them for keeping this issue under control without sacrificing that intensity or that chaos.
• There isn’t a ton of dialogue in this issue, but what little dialogue there is shows how rich and bold the cast of this series is. Not every character has a lot of chances to shine, but Bryan Glass makes them stand off with poignant dialogue that keeps the story moving forward.
• Everything about this issue screams EPIC. This is just a HUGE story with HUGE moments, HUGE action, and HUGE characters. For a story that started about a quiet little village, its amazing how big it has gotten without ever losing any of its charm. Glass has been building to this issue from day one and he does not disappoint.
• The art is what wins it for this issue though as Victor Santos puts on a career-making showcase. No one can ever doubt Santos’ ability or potential after looking at this issue…EVER.
• Santos takes advantage of the expanded page count by using larger, more action packed panels as well as lots of great splash pages and some of the best looking spreads of the years.
• When dealing with animal characters, it is difficult to display strong expressions without making the characters too human. This is not a problem for Santos as his expressions transcend the fact that he is drawing mice. He doesn’t try to slap human expressions on them, but instead draws some of the best mouse expressions you’ll ever see.
• I also really, really dig that Santos thinks outside the box with his inventive approach to layouts and storytelling. The structures of the pages themselves become part of the story here. It’s hard to explain without having an example to show you. You really need to just buy the comic for yourself and revel in its storytelling glory.
• A lot of credit for the success of the art belongs to colorist Veronica Gandini, whose bold color choices and fantastic textures really bring Santos’s line work to life.

Verdict: Must Read. As I said in my first bullet point, I hold Mice Templar to an almost unnecessarily high standard compared to most comics that I read each week and I have never been disappointed as Bryan Glass and company always meet and often exceed those expectations. They have never exceeded my expectations quite like this. This is simply incredible comic book storytelling from start to finish as every single member of the creative team puts forth one of the finest works of their respective careers. As this phenomenal franchise closes out its second volume, the bar has been raised even higher thanks to this issue, not only the Book of the Week, but one of the finest comics of the year.

Related Posts


Anonymous said...

what about invincible?

Anonymous said...

Mice Templar would not be in the same league as anything Grant Morrison would write.

Let's face facts.

Ryan Schrodt said...

@Anonymous#1 - I've never read Invincible, actually. I keep meaning to buy it in trade, but there are so many other trades I need to buy first.

Joe said...

Seriously , NO Brightest Day? You guys can't even try to be objective ?!?

Radlum said...

Why would Ryan rank BD if he dropped after last issue?

Ivan said...

OH MY GOD. Some people just can't get the concept of an amateur blog done with money out of the owner's pocket, huh?

They won't support a work they're not pleased with simply for "fairness's" sake. They're comic book fans who happen to critique their pull list. This is not Newsarama, CBR or CA.

Anonymous said...

Star Wars: lecacy is cancelled now :-(

Ryan Schrodt said...

@Joe - I'm not sure how I'm not being objective by dropping Brightest Day. It's not very good and I have to buy all my own comics. Also, the vast majority of the comics I read are from DC. I'm sorry that I'm not reviewing comics that you like, but unless you want to buy me comics I don't want to pay to read, it won't be on the Rankings.

@Anonymous#7 - They announced it a few months back, but the interview with Ostrander and Duursema this week on CBR made it sound like it was coming from the Lucas folks, as they have lots of Legacy stories they want to tell. Hopefully this won't be the last we see of that era as the comic has been really great from day one.

Flip The Page said...

@joe man, you need to learn the definition of objective if you're seriously applying it to CRITICAL REVIEWS.

But yeah Brightest Day was given a chance by them all and it underwhelmed and offended. I don't see why that'd mean they have to keep spending their money to not enjoy something.... unless you're Ryan and his Teen Titans torture

Ryan Schrodt said...

@Flip the Page - Don't remind me! I can't believe how long I held onto Teen Titans before finally dropping it last month. I couldn't help it though, the Ravager story was awesome and I love the Titans. I kept hoping it would get better, even when I knew it wouldn't.

GS said...

@Joe - Honestly, what exactly was there to review in BD? We get more questions involving Deadman's purpose, more gorn courtesy of Martian Manhunter probing a dog's mind, more Aquaman summoning dead fish and not being all that concerned about it, more Ronnie Raymond being an insensitive moron, and more Hawkman stuff (which admittedly might be picking up next week). I know that 52 wasn't running at full steam at issue four, but at least it had you somewhat invested in the characters. I know I'm not the only one who really doesn't care what happens to any character in the story at this point, and I'm a fan of several of the resurrected heroes.

Anonymous said...

Joe man can not you see? they will buy any marvel comic even if it is crap for example siege and continue buying it just for the fact that it is marvel.

It is so easy so try to understand you moron

Anonymous said...

They were objective enough when they called this site the marvel crisis, at least they accpeted the enormous bias to the Marvel side and their hate about all DC related, call it readers, comic books, creators movies etc.

Thanks God there are OBJECTIVE blogs out there

Tye said...

Hahaha i can't beleive this site was relatively troll free for so long. Don't like the reviews - DONT READ.

Love the site guys keep it up!!

Anonymous said...

I think that there are a lot of DC folks who do not like to be pissed off. And this is immature from both sides marvel and dc fans, of course

Ryan K Lindsay said...

Hey, yeah, we were troll free for so long. Who opened the feeding pen?;)

As for objective, man, I'll never understand...I will admit some reviewers bought Siege an issue or two after they worked out it was crap, but that was for a 4 issue mini, not a 26 issue commitment. But so long as we fund these things we'll only buy what we like, or think we might like. And look at Marvel on these rankings, only one Marvel U book got anything it decent, the higher up was not Marvel.

@Anon13 - Can you please let me know the OBJECTIVE blogs you do read and like, and I'm not being sarcastic, I love adding more comic blogs to my Google feed.

Anonymous said...

I think that there are a lot of DC folks who do not like to be pissed off. And this is immature from both sides marvel and dc fans, of course but I see more marvelites spitting on dc fanbase

Ryan Schrodt said...

I really don't understand why it has to be "Marvel vs. DC." Seriously, I'm assuming most of you are grown adults, so by now you should be rational and mature enough to realize that comics are not inherently good just because they are produced by one company. That is ridiculously narrow-minded. A good comic is a good comic, no matter who publishes it.

Anonymous said...

I love how many times DC books like SECRET SIX have won the #1 spot on this supposedly "Marvel" biased site.

Great work, guys!
Keep it up and keep it real!

Daryll B. said...

Ryan S., in this way comic fans are like wrestling fans. It isn't enough to just like the overall medium, you HAVE to blindly like one company over all others no matter what CWAP they put out....

Some fans really need to grow up and understand that no one these days makes enough money to constantly pay for cwap at these prices.

On to the list, I have to say I like McCann's writing style....

And is there any comic writer as underestimated as Nicieza is? He can mold his style seemingly to any curveball a universe throws at him. He did it with Robin... he did it with the x-titles... he did it with the New Warriors... and now he's back at it with Red Robin

Anonymous said...



Have a question, I remember that I read somewhere that if Galactus is killed the universe would collapse because he is part of the universe or something like that.... was that retconned? or I missunderstood that?

oakleyses said...

michael kors outlet online, tiffany jewelry, tiffany and co, longchamp outlet, burberry outlet, prada outlet, jordan shoes, nike air max, nike free, michael kors outlet online, oakley sunglasses, christian louboutin shoes, tory burch outlet, nike air max, polo ralph lauren outlet online, kate spade outlet, michael kors outlet online, burberry handbags, christian louboutin, oakley sunglasses, kate spade, polo outlet, christian louboutin uk, ray ban sunglasses, coach outlet, coach outlet store online, longchamp outlet, replica watches, christian louboutin outlet, longchamp outlet, coach outlet, ray ban sunglasses, chanel handbags, michael kors outlet, michael kors outlet, oakley sunglasses wholesale, prada handbags, michael kors outlet store, gucci handbags, nike outlet

oakleyses said...

timberland pas cher, jordan pas cher, polo ralph lauren, nike free run, sac longchamp pas cher, michael kors pas cher, burberry pas cher, new balance, nike air force, north face, michael kors, vans pas cher, mulberry uk, nike blazer pas cher, hollister pas cher, nike roshe, lululemon canada, louboutin pas cher, guess pas cher, sac vanessa bruno, sac hermes, converse pas cher, nike air max, true religion jeans, longchamp pas cher, hogan outlet, ralph lauren uk, nike tn, ray ban uk, north face uk, oakley pas cher, air max, true religion outlet, true religion outlet, hollister uk, ray ban pas cher, coach purses, true religion outlet, polo lacoste, michael kors outlet

oakleyses said...

jimmy choo outlet, asics running shoes, instyler, vans outlet, nike roshe run, chi flat iron, soccer shoes, ghd hair, insanity workout, hermes belt, nike huaraches, nike trainers uk, bottega veneta, babyliss, ferragamo shoes, mont blanc pens, abercrombie and fitch, nike air max uk, mac cosmetics, longchamp uk, celine handbags, north face outlet, nike roshe run uk, beats by dre, nike air max uk, wedding dresses, new balance shoes, lululemon, north face outlet, soccer jerseys, nfl jerseys, giuseppe zanotti outlet, p90x workout, valentino shoes, herve leger, abercrombie and fitch uk, hollister, mcm handbags, nike free uk, reebok outlet

oakleyses said...

nike air max, vans, baseball bats, montre pas cher, converse, juicy couture outlet, iphone 6 cases, links of london, pandora charms, pandora jewelry, lancel, juicy couture outlet, swarovski, pandora uk, marc jacobs, thomas sabo, karen millen uk, wedding dresses, supra shoes, hollister, replica watches, ray ban, swarovski crystal, converse outlet, timberland boots, nike air max, toms shoes, coach outlet, louboutin, hollister clothing, oakley, hollister, gucci, ralph lauren

Post a Comment

Thanks for checking out the Weekly Crisis - Comic Book Review Blog. Comments are always appreciated. You can sign in and comment with any Google, Wordpress, Live Journal, AIM, OpenID or TypePad account.