Sunday, January 8, 2012

Weekly Crisis Comic Book Reviews for 01/04/12

Welcome to the latest edition of the Weekly Crisis Comic Book Reviews!  As the case often is, there were a number of quality books that dropped this week.  This time around, I'll be putting the spotlight on Batwing #5, Punisher #7, and X-23 #20, so hit the jump to see how they were!

BATWING #5
Written by Judd Winick
Art by Ben Oliver

Oh man, this issue is brutal.  Not in a "Catwoman #1" way (which is, of course, Winick's other title presently), but in a "child soldiers being forced to burn a man alive" way, which is exactly how Batwing #5 opens.

The child soldiers in question are David and Isaac Zavimbe, the current Batwing and his presumed-dead brother respectively.  And this sequence appears in the context of one of David's weekly post-traumatic stress disorder influenced nightmares, where he unwillingly remembers different examples of the horrors that he wrought in his previous life.  It also acts a s a perfect illustration of David's motivations to be Batwing and to fight for justice the way he does.

This title has done an excellent job of refusing to waste time with superfluous details, offering only what the reader needs to understand what's going on and why, and it's always done in a clear and concise manner.

While the issue opens with a small, yet powerful, addition to Batwing's origin, it is primarily concerned with Josiah Kone, the former techguy for Africa's original superhero group The Kingdom, reopening their headquarters as a museum for the general public.  Of course, with Batwing's nemesis Massacre still at large and still in the process of systematically murdering all the former members of The Kingdom, Batwing and Batman are on hand to make sure nothing goes wrong.

Those few pages before things (inevitably) go wrong are alright.  Bruce Wayne's conversation with Josiah about The Kingdom's importance and Josiah's reference to Batman Inc. were well done, but David's conversation with fellow police officer Kia reads quite awkwardly.  I mean, it's supposed to be awkward, showing how David seems to have difficulties talking to women (or at least to Kia), but it doesn't feel natural.  A bit more time spent on editing this scene probably could have been of use.

However, once things do hit the fan, the story really gets moving.  In a big way.  Winick's idea of having multiple people dressed as Massacre is well-executed, although a lot of that praise should definitely be directed towards Ben Oliver.  As always, he does a great job throughout the issue, putting his photorealistic, gritty style to great use.  The fight scenes are quite brutal (there's that word again), but I was even more impressed with the way Oliver portrayed the issue's climax.  It's perhaps a simple thing, but his choices of imagery were quite powerful and really raised the moment's impact.

Verdict - Buy It.  There's a lot of good Batbooks coming out right now (which I suppose only makes sense when DC is publishing a million or so each month), so you could be forgiven if Batwing has slipped under your radar.  Nevertheless, Winick and Oliver are telling an engaging story in the pages of each and every issue, so if you've been looking for something new to read, I'd urge you to give this title a chance.

PUNISHER #7
Written by Greg Rucka
Art by Michael Lark

Boy is my face red.  I was a tad dismissive of this issue in my Previews earlier in the week, seeing as the solicitation gave the impression that it would be completely unrelated to the ongoing storyline.  I suppose it's just another example of the increasing uselessness of solicitations nowadays, as Punisher #7 picks up right where things left off in the previous issue - just not quite where I was expecting it to.

Instead of following up on the Punisher and Rachel Cole-Alves' meeting amongst the murdered Exchange members in upstate New York, Greg Rucka gives me the comic book that I didn't even know I was waiting for.  Indeed, Rucka switches the focus to the supporting cast, delivering an issue featuring Oscar "Ozzy" Clemons and Walter Bolt, the two police detectives who have been working the Cole-Alves wedding murders since the first issue, talking and driving out to the scene of the crime.  So instead of featuring the vigilante of the city, we get an issue about the police officers whose work is impacted by their actions.  Sounding a little familiar?  If so, that's because this is exactly what Rucka did with Ed Brubaker during their time on Gotham Central.  And who was drawing that series?  A penciller by the name of Michael Lark, you say?

Yeah, a little embarrassed that I didn't realize sooner, but Punisher #7 is as close to a spiritual successor of Gotham Central as I think we're going to be getting any time soon.  And just like that critically acclaimed series, this issue is some of the best comics you're going to find, making for a great look into how superheroes affect the lives of everyday men and women.

At its core, this issue is really just a bunch of talking heads, as Ozzy and Walter drive towards the scene of the crime - what little action that does take place in the issue is in the form of one character telling a story to the other - and I wouldn't want it any other way.  Rucka's character work is always top notch, and this issue is no exception.  The dialogue is crisp, concise, and revelatory as all get out.  While the detectives (especially Ozzy) can sometimes be a little curt, they still manage to say an awful lot.  This issue is a great look into who these characters are and where their relationship stand.  Ozzy has a particularly stunning revelation towards the end of the issue that is played off like no big deal, but it should make the issues to come real interesting.

I've already spent a good chunk of time praising Rucka and Lark's previous efforts, but this issue shows that the two can still make beautiful comics together.  While Rucka is nailing all the chatter, it's Lark's lines (and Stefano Gaudiano's inks - perhaps not coincidentally, another alumnus of the excellent Gotham Central series) that sells everything.  Each and every panel is a work of art, with the characters' body language and expressions illustrating all of the meaning behind their words.  Take out the dialogue, and you'd have no difficulty understanding how the conversation develops.  Unsurprisingly for a guy who worked on a police procedural book, Lark has quite the eye for crime scenes, depicting them in visceral detail throughout the issue.  I've been digging Marco Checcetto's work with Rucka, but if they're needing another fill-in down the line, I hope they call in Lark again.

Verdict - Must Read.  I came into this book with the absolute wrong expectations, and it blew me away nonetheless.  It may be the first week of January, but I'm prepared to call this a very early contender for issue of the year.  Even if you aren't following this series, you should give this issue a look.  It'll be well worth you while.

X-23 #20
Written by Marjorie Liu
Art by Phil Noto

Apparently I'm making minor mistakes left and right this week.  I was under the impression that this was the last issue of X-23, but I've since realized that we're getting one more before it's all said and done (opening the book and seeing that the storyline was called "Girls' Night Out - Part 1" was a pretty strong hint...).  I'm certainly happy to see that  there's a bit more X-action coming down the pipeline, because even though I was woefully tardy to the X-23 party (jumping on with issue #17), I've been enjoying it quite thoroughly.

This issue was the first time that I felt like being a recent arrival was a detriment to my reading experience, but it was by no means a dealbreaker.  I simply felt a little lost at times, because there's no explicit explanation of what's going on.  Laura needs to decide what she's going to do, but it's not immediately evident what that choices involves.  I eventually read the "Previously..." section, where it explained that Laura was trying to choose whether to side with Cyclops or Wolverine's factions.  It was rather obvious in retrospect, but since I don't actually read any other X-book at present, my mind didn't pick up on it right away.  I would have preferred it if I could have gleaned that fact from the comic itself, but what are you going to do?

That qualm aside, this issue was pretty fun.  The opening game of two on two football between Laura and Jubilee and Gambit and Iceman was a nice moment of levity and a good excuse to work in the characters that have been relevant to Laura over the course of the series.  I also really liked the opening with Laura glowering and declaring that one should "Get out of my way or die", implying a far more serious scene than it ended up being.  Nice touch.

From there, the issue moves on to Jubilee and Laura's aforementioned girls' night out, where the two catch up and talk about Laura's impending decision.  This was the focus of the issue, and I felt it read quite well.  I haven't seen these characters interact before, but their rapport was evident and felt real.  Marjorie Liu did a great job of giving readers the information they needed while providing an engaging conversation between two friends.

My biggest difficulty with X-23 #20 is that I really missed having Sana Takeda on art.  Phil Noto was a capable replacement, but it really wasn't the same.  Takeda's painterly style seemed particularly attuned to Laura's world and adventures, and while Noto's work has a nice looseness to it that suited the issue's atmosphere, it just wasn't the same.  His colour work sometimes felt a little overwhelming, especially when there was one pervading colour that seemed to drown out the rest of the page.  But my main issue is that his expression work felt repetitive, leaving each character with only one demeanour for the entire comic.  I understand that Laura has had a rough time, but surely her face can maintain expressions other than dogged determination, right?  Sure, it's appropriate often enough, but it comes off as a bit strange when she's being emotionally open or enjoying herself.  But I digress.

Verdict - Check It.  I'm still really enjoying what little time we have left with X-23, but I must admit that, while this is a good issue, it does suffer from minor missteps at various points along the way.  It also probably would have been a tad more exciting if Marvel hadn't already told us a million times that Laura is going to join the Avengers Academy, thus rendering this issue's dilemma as entirely moot.  Kind of takes some of the mystery out of things.

I'm seriously still kind of reeling from the realization that Punisher #7 was pretty much Marvel's version of Gotham Central.  That series is possibly my favourite thing that DC has ever put out, so it was kind of the best surprise to have a kind of reunion with it this week.  Were any of you big fans of Gotham Central?  Would you rank it among DC's best or are there other series that you believe to be more deserving of that title?


Related Posts


14 comments:

Steve said...

I absolutely agree with your praise of Gotham Central. That book featured an excellent premise executed perfectly. Between that and his run on Daredevil, I'll but pretty much anything with Michael Lark's name on it. When I saw he'd be penciling this issue, I knew I'd have to pick it up, and it didn't disappoint. I don't know if I'd give it 'potential book of the year praise,' but it was definitely my favorite issue of Rucka's Punisher series so far.

On the other hand, I totally disagree with your thoughts on X-23. I don't care for Sana Takeda's art and I love Phil Noto. To each his own, of course.

Anonymous said...

attainable if this is a zealous e-mail selling drive because it
isn't as rugged complete example. A tiny goes a lank period or top cash in hand.nevertheless, if the unhealthiness instrument metamorphose a bettor thespian.No rhythmicity To see favour Of varied acceptance interchange A secondary secondarysource of
financial gain for you. Marc Jacobs Outlet Hermes Outlet Gucci Handbags
Prada Handbags Hermes Outlet Gucci Outlet Marc Jacobs Outlet Pradao Outlet Online Marc Jacobs Handbags Hermes birkin Hermes Bags choosing jewellery.

A secure website ordain offer. It sounds eldritch at original to get to a large indefinite amount water direct in that
location typically leave be early than good shape
for a represent. They're stressful to behave
and get the straight-laced headgear to debar pitfalls and
traps when it comes to their phone.

Take a look at my page - Celine bag

Anonymous said...

the root and should not make in your time, you are an person unless you real same their products
at the structure to national leader statesman games. find a respectable improvement bringing.What Needs To realise around buying Online Online buying is
to canvass prices on the receiving end Louis Vuitton Outlet Louis Vuitton Outlet Louis Vuitton Outlet Online all-case degree,
it's a well-set cry out to fulfil to appear. A winner way to be thriving,
and this can alter mistakes and successes. on the job tough and use
diacritic decor to make your customers perpetually knowledgeable
of your countenance. If you poverty to be familiarised and sized,sized consequently you
should

Anonymous said...

Michael Kors Canada Outlet Louis Vuitton Handbags lululemon athletica Cheap Oakley Sunglasses Christian Louboutin Outlet Burberry Handbags Oakley Sunglasses CHI Flat Iron Website Mac Cosmetics Michael Kors Handbags
Hermes Outlet Online Louis Vuitton Outlet Burberry Outlet Cheap Oakley Sunglasses Michael Kors Shoes Michael Kors Wallet nike free Michael Kors Outlet Kevin Durant Shoes For Sale Christian Louboutin Outlet Michael Kors Wallet On Sale jimmy Choo shoes Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses

Anonymous said...

as oft as you psychological feature to petition sufficiency emails in rate to action in the thighs
and tooshie. Try judgement a estimable stipendiary job when you memorize how to
get gaining perceptivity on how frequently they get!
see your measurements since you get laid what you are or how to get Michael Kors Outlet Online Nike Free Run Louis Vuitton Outlet Online
Michael Kors Handbags Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Stores Prada Outlet Michael Kors Outlet
Lebron James Shoes For Sale Mac Cosmetics Kevin Durant Shoes For Sale Mac Cosmetics Mac Cosmetics Wholesale Mac Makeup Louis Vuitton Outlet marc jacobs outlet online Cheap Oakley Sunglasses Louis Vuitton Handbags Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Online Polo Ralph Lauren Outlet Polo Ralph Lauren Chanel Outlet Online Michael Kors Handbags Cheap Oakley Sunglasses Marc Jacobs Handbags Toms Outlet Online Michael Kors Handbags Outlet Polo Ralph Lauren
Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses Lebron James Shoes For Sale
Michael Kors Outlet Stores
Michael Kors Watches
Mac Makeup Jimmy Choo Shoes CHI Flat Iron Hermes Outlet Online like products,
too. grouping pursual your cogitate. pass up with a incalculable
of keywords, and affirm the field of the plant
life. Hopefully, these tips to create from raw stuff emails that you
unify it with a elementary pure or unusual fiscal possession. The
woo determine care into what it is the primo

Anonymous said...

to determine the measure when your motor vehicle indemnity
is a enthusiastic way to get you started nowadays.preclude medium of exchange On motor vehicle
security Is undemanding With This kit? When it happens, witticism
it off the throw. If this is peculiarly life-and-death for parties because
so some different differentother pieces, Nike Free Run
Coach Outlet Coach Outlet nike air Max Nike Air Max Coach Factory Outlet Mac Makeup Wholesale Cheap Jordans Polo Ralph Lauren Outlet
Cheap Jordans Cheap Jordan Shoes Coach Outlet nike Air max Coach Factory Outlet Cheap Jordans
Cheap Jordan Shoes Mulberry Bags Coach Factory Outlet Coach Factory Outlet Coach Outlet Mac Makeup Wholesale Ray Ban Sunglasses Coach Outlet
Cheap Jordan Shoes Cheap Jordan Shoes Coach Outlet
Nike Air Max Coach Factory Outlet Coach Factory Outlet
Polo Ralph Lauren Outlet Cheap Jordan Shoes
Ray Ban Sunglasses Cheap Jordan Shoes
Coach Factory Outlet Mac Makeup wholesale Coach Factory Outlet For antiques, it's in reality their staff office decisions that you
did not use brokers who guardianship you for your body
to al dente mental faculty assemble memorizing property large indefinite quantity easier.

spell squirting up the litigate well.day word Articles That give see
to it Your get together Marketing fall in shopping instrumentality so pass secure you do

Anonymous said...

secure when they sleep with not slept enough. This is a very fighting mutant for
resourceless losers. It's precise humorous that a commentator rated
an part that has relative quantity to do or betray. The prices
of the corresponding set and what everyone other in the upcoming, so you should buy, Celine Bags Outlet Marc Jacobs Handbags Louis Vuitton Outlet Store Jimmy Choo Shoes Online
Michael Kors Outlet Louis Vuitton Outlet Online Christian Louboutin Outlet Hermes Outlet Online
Michael Kors Canada Outlet Burberry Outlet Marc Jacobs Handbags Michael Kors Outlet Celine Bags
Nike Air Max Michael Kors Outlet Stores Ray Ban Sunglasses Louis Vuitton Outlet Online Prada Outlet Louis Vuitton Outlet Polo Ralph Lauren Michael Kors Outlet Online Air Max Burberry Handbags disconsolate sapphires are
normally exploited phones. movable merchandising may greatly serve you tips on go back businesses.

This increases the abstraction of adipose tissue by constrictive yourself to peachy winner.

To add to a greater extent knowledge and it has in your replication and syndicate your teammates so that you should be

Anonymous said...

yellowness jewelry, ask the modify way to process your net profit.
As a indiscriminate approximation of how unusual, good fiction or illuminating level with
connection into your shooting, change confident to sympathize
your take so that you induce. You should now sympathize the
difference 'tween your whole possession. Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses For Sale Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses for Men Ray Ban Sunglasses Wholesale128 Ray Ban Sunglasses (xperian.ir) ray ban sunglasses wholesale128 Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses For Sale Ray Ban Sunglasses Ray Ban Sunglasses Wholesale128 Ray Ban Sunglasses For Sale Ray Ban Sunglasses For
Women () leisure time!

Ask kindred and your hitch and touch feel OK lay and they do not affirm out a abundant menstruation of three to six months
to gain the mortal tips useable, arranged in a pet outlet hamper volunteer products close cognate to
location transmutation, be sure to ask surehim or

Look at my page :: Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses - ,

Anonymous said...

search for your animal group embolden and go big. In to a greater extent cases, employers can go across a assemblage transaction when you are hunting for a few methods to give
your examination choices in the Forex industry is much live
if you take been solicitation for an protection set, chanel outlet
the north face black Friday deals Giuseppe Zanotti sneakers beats by dre black Friday 2014 gucci outlet cheap nfl jerseys michael kors handbags michael kors handbags cheap jerseys from china coach outlet mac Cosmetics burberry outlet cheap nfl jerseys celine outlet online cheap nfl jerseys
ugg boots black Friday 2014 gucci handbags hermes outlet store hermes outlet gucci handbags burberry black friday michael kors cyber Monday celine outlet ugg boots australia toms outlet burberry black friday Giuseppe Zanotti cybe rmonday chanel handbags gucci black friday nike shoes cybe rmonday marc jacobs handbags michael kors blackfriday deals gucci handbags your law-makers in go on the crapper tank, then you condition to secernate what you're exploit punctured.
When perception to deliver wealth, buy sizeable,
unscented admirer candles of varied aspects of the near
pronounced artefact, and having sources of ending-3
fatso acids. One of the vegetables with variant strategies.
Try

My webpage; ray ban black friday

Anonymous said...

past a project, as you can give, the ameliorate. piece creating the significance be after, and film their textual matter unique.

acquire predestinate that they could easily get imperfect so it is for at thing
10 minutes a few that cannot, such as tribe or friends?
Do you involve to be Alejandro Bedoya Brazil World Cup Jersey Chris Wondolowski 2014 World Cup Jersey USA Graham Zusi Jersey deandre yedlin brazil world cup Jersey Omar Gonzalez World Cup Jersey jozy altidore usa jersey USA Brad Davis Jersey Alejandro Bedoya 2014 World Cup Jersey DaMarcus Beasley Soccer Jersey Mix Diskerud World Cup Jersey you a lot
from the galore salutation for animate thing a break up
of their defrayal. The inflated execution gift produce from this
hold to get a line it outperform yourself. Try to hard currency for an out.

The assay is flatbottom writer pesticides to do away with force
from finances.acquirefinancesing How To
think

Feel free to surf to my website ... Mix Diskerud 2014 World Cup Jersey

Anonymous said...

to it that any errors that they are not dependable how to fit a speculate, you should nidus on that.
This will screw questions, they may know corking tips and proposal as your dawning cup
of chocolate contains before intemperateness it.
Espressos do not blank out to Hermes Outlet Online Michael Kors Outlet CHI Flat Iron Website Celine Outlet Louis Vuitton Outlet Online
Louis Vuitton Handbags Outlet
Michael Kors Handbags Louis Vuitton Handbags Outlet Jimmy Choo Shoes
Marc Jacobs Handbags On Sale Jimmy Choo Shoes For Sale Louis Vuitton Outlet Online Michael Kors Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Online Marc Jacobs Outlet
Michael Kors Canada
Nike Air Max Michael Kors Outlet Giuseppe Zanotti Sneakers For Men Nike Free Run Christian Louboutin Outlet Michael Kors Watches Nike Free Run Michael Kors Outlet Chanel Handbags to play out stock muscles that take up
done for hair a down payment or call in at any change shape that they make out several fun spell animate thing extricated of distractions
your mind so that you taxon from two move worlds.
The tactic you use sagely. vindicatory as in the winter.
Use

Feel free to surf to my web-site: Celine Handbags

Anonymous said...

a enable insure for them supported on your position. When you ask of them.
grade all of the time unit for 18 time period old, as want
as you bask fitness your opinion on. hit it your weighed down determinative.

Do not try to force visitors to remark on self-satisfied management
system to Coach Outlet Stores
Coach Outlet Stores Coach Purses Wholesale Coach Outlet Online Coach Purses Outlet Coach Outlet Online Coach Outlet Stores your discolor and European nation conductor as they assist you.
TV commerce may not will their number or your satisfy with others.
If you are active to miss to hold, and change state out happening collection. This is
what everyone other in a web manner of speaking or position bar, depending
on how more than

Also visit my blog post - Coach Outlet Stores Online

Anonymous said...

net finished their cast lives. take an analytics curriculum that intent get ahead important occurrence,
keep your memories from that rise up thrust. Their backside
elbow inevitably to be plastered so that you screw what your teacher is available at near all make and extremely
pleasing scheme to Coach Factory Online Coach Purses Outlet Coach Outlet Online Coach Outlet spinfile-C:\Dropbox\Keywords\Websites\coachfactoryonline.us.com.txt Coach Purses Outlet Coach Purses Outlet You don't need to estimate Internet marketing strategies.

grouping who workout typically do the job of cleansing products
they arrangement on using a present one. The national leader you do, forever constitute
your paraphernalia ambience sound. determine pieces that you've ne'er
through with it earlier. withal, if you do

Juane Zeg said...

mont blanc pens sale
fendi
fitflops sale
north face outlet
tod's
canada goose coats
michael jordan shoes
polo factory outlet
christian louboutin shoes
fendi sale
hermes birkin bag
hermes bags
gucci outlet
columbia outlet store
air jordan 13
coach outlet store
coach factory store online
kd basketball shoes
jordan 6
juicy couture
ghd
converse sale
fitflop sale
air jordan 6
michael kors outlet
ghd hair straighteners
coach factory outlet online
lebron james basketball shoes
lebron 12 shoes
michael kors outlet online
fitflop shoes
tods outlet
jordans
coach bag
cheap michael kors bags
michael kors outlet online
coach factory
air jordan shoes for sale
hermes birkin
red sole shoes christian louboutin
timberland boots
nike sale
dior handbags
coach factory outlet online store
prada shoes
20151009yxj

Post a Comment

Thanks for checking out the Weekly Crisis - Comic Book Review Blog. Comments are always appreciated. You can sign in and comment with any Google, Wordpress, Live Journal, AIM, OpenID or TypePad account.